Skip to main content

Would Jesus Wear Skinny Jeans?


4 principles for the fusion of church and culture

Would Jesus wear skinny jeans and a cardigan while listening to Mumford? Or would he continue rocking the traditional Jewish garb of his day? Perhaps he would only wear Ralph Lauren and listen exclusively to K-love. Or maybe he would wear a suit and prefer hymns.

The modern day church is fraught with controversy surrounding the fusion of church and culture. Many well- meaning people from diverse perspectives land in a variety of positions on polarizing issues -- and rightfully so since there is no clear line between what is sacred and secular. I would propose that we stop making this distinction all together. Labeling some areas of our lives ‘sacred’ and others ‘secular’ is a new idea in the scope of things. It is a dangerous idea too because it practically forces us into double standards. It encourages us to live in an unnatural state of tension, nervously trying to put everything we encounter into a nicely labeled box.

In order to address this huge issue, I must zoom in on a part of it so I will address ‘art’ in this post. The tension is thick here. Many Christians are opposed to the creation and spreading of art that is not ‘sacred’? But this tension arises from a worldview that views art as primarily ‘secular’ and which seems to inform a large portion of the American church.

To zoom in even closer, I have chosen to look at the debates that often arise in a microcosm called “worship services”. Many people are hesitant to integrate ‘secular things’ into these services. Should the stage set and its people look similar to a Coldplay show? Or should the church be completely disconnected from the cultural norms? What principles should govern how we interact with these things? The 3 artistic expressions I address below will hopefully give us clarity on the larger issue at stake here: how integrated should the church be with the surrounding culture?

Lights

Many people believe theatrical lighting makes the worship service feel more like a show or performance than a genuine atmosphere for worship. I understand this. The objects of worship are not the instrumentalists on stage. Yet, I seriously disagree with the idea that colored light shows are secular. After all, who designed “blue”? Whose idea was it to give humans eyes to experience color? Why isn’t everything in black and white? Who made specific colors trigger certain emotions within us? Have you ever seen a sunset over water? The Northern Lights? When God imagined His canvas, it was covered with brilliant and radiant colors that stimulate something beautiful within us -- and God Himself set it there. Why should our eyes not be allowed to worship along with our hearts, hands, and mouths?

Music

Music is other. It has the ability to connect us with God like nothing else can. Why? God designed it that way. Writing, playing, and singing music can be an extremely godly activity, yet some Christians are hesitant to allow creativity to flourish in this area. Some people get frustrated by the fresh expressions emerging on the scene and discount its validity by saying we are trying too hard to emulate the culture around us and should stick to the songs we already have. But why would we ever do such a thing? Our young worship leaders aren’t trying to emulate the culture with their new songs; they are authentically producing art consistent with the culture that has shaped their taste. It is impossible to escape the reality that we are all products of our culture. Not one single person is exempt from being shaped by the culture around them. One of the most important things a worship leader can have is a genuinely expressive heart – and we have to come to grips with the truth that their expressions will sound like they originated in 2013… because they did.

Fashion

Everyone on stage during a worship service used to wear a suit. Now, you might catch someone wearing skinny jeans and a cardigan. I have gathered that some people think the reason this happens is because the people on stage are trying to be like everyone else in the culture. This might be true but only in the way that people who buy flat screen HDTV’s and new cars and who get their hair cut at the salon are trying to be like everyone else. If we go to someone’s house and they have a 23” black and white TV in the center of their living room, shag carpet, an 88’ Chevy Corsica in their garage, a bowl cut, and bell bottoms, we might assume they are rather confused about what era it is. Look around your house and notice how shaped by the modern culture you really are. Fashion is trendy and it changes with time. So it is reasonable to assume that the reason the people on stage are wearing whatever it is they have on is because it is what they have in their closet. It might even be the nicest looking thing they have in their closet.

 
1 // The line between sacred and secular is hard to find – because we shouldn’t be looking for it

 There are plenty of things that aren’t sacred but none of them have been discussed in this post. Many of the things we consider secular are just abuses of sacred things. Most sin is a result of our abuse or idolization of sex, dominion, and plants – all gifts given to humans by God in Genesis 1-2.

2 // The less integrated the church becomes, the less influence we have.

I’m no longer talking about worship services – I’m talking about the church. You and I and the 2 billion others we share a body with cannot separate ourselves from the culture. We are the salt of the earth – we give it flavor! We are the city on a hill, broadcasting light to the whole world! To isolate ourselves is at best unnecessary and at worst paralyzing.

3 // Everything God designed was to help us engage with Him on a more profound level

God’s creation is supposed to draw us in. The world is a massive showcase of God’s majesty and love – and all of it should lead us into an awe and reverence for Him. When encountered correctly, all creation draws us into a deeper communion with our Father.

4 //The church should be at the forefront of innovation and creation.

 We are intimately connected to the Cosmic Artist, the one who dreamed up and designed everything you and I experience and see. Shouldn’t we be the people at the forefront of producing impactful, influential, and original art? I think so.

 

Comments

  1. All excellent points and very well written.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I recently shared a sermon where I used the "National Anthem" from the Boston Bruins hockey game. A memorable moment after the bombing at the Boston Marathon. Audience one had an average age of 40+. Audience two had an average age of 16. Audience one, stood, placed their hands over their hearts, and sang with the video. Audience two sat, watched and wondered what the point of the intro was. Two demographics see moments very differently. Our church should be full of both, so we would do well to recognize your conclusions. We aren't just fusing church and culture, but church past and present with culture past and present.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post, and I wholeheartedly agree. Not being of this world doesn't necessarily mean we have to hide from it. Thanks for your thoughts!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you everyone for the comments! I think there is much more to be written around this subject. We need to engage in these discussions regularly so we can begin to grasp how complicated this whole thing really is and realize why slapping labels on things and moving on isn't particularly helpful.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

She's a Maneater: 5 reasons ministers are leaving 'the church' in record numbers

Every day men and women who had once felt commissioned by God to spend their life serving His church walk away from it. The statistics are staggering: anywhere from 60-80% of pastors leave full time ministry before they ever reach the 10 year mark. Many of these people don’t just quit their jobs; they lose all hope in the institutionalized church. Many go on to extend the kingdom in profound and creative ways. Others end up holding a deep disdain for anything remotely resembling the institutions that pushed them away. And still some who have been burned ‘stay’ but wrap themselves in the security blanket of isolation and routine. This is a devastating state of affairs.
Perhaps the greatest travesty in the western church is that we have so severely wounded and pushed away those who were most passionate about movement and reform. Why do the people who set out to serve us end up running from us? And why does the body of Christ not rush to these wounded ones to help them heal and recover …

The Modern Family

Homosexuality is one of the most polarizing issues in our world. The gay rights movement has been one of the most successful movements in recent memory, nailing their strategy of swinging the pendulum of an entire culture from “it’s unnatural” to “it’s completely normal” - from “we can’t talk about that” to “we see that every day” – all in less than 30 years. Homosexuality is also one of the most difficult issues to address in America because the minute anyone asks questions about it, they are profiled as close minded and unintelligent, ridiculed for holding such an ‘old fashioned’ view. It has gotten to a point where very few people will voice their opposition to the movement for fear of who they might offend or how they might be ridiculed.

I am not going to talk about homosexuals here; rather homosexuality. After all, one of the strokes of genius for the gay rights movement was to make it impossible to talk about the issue of homosexuality apart from “attacking” real people. Their s…

If Jesus has to be first, I would like to be second (4 myths about church leadership)

Myth #1 / I am the head of Christ’s body

We are becoming obsessed with church leadership. Entire movements and organizations have been built on teaching people how to become better leaders. I got caught up in this culture for a long time. It is one that relies heavily on the sentiment that every local church needs a strong visionary leader at its forefront in order to be successful – a sort of Moses if you will. But Moses never wanted the job in the first place. He didn’t feel qualified and the truth is that He wasn’t. However, that is precisely the point. The people who play the most significant roles in the story are typically those that didn’t really do anything of themselves. Rather, God accomplished things through them that they clearly could have never done on their own strength.
What every local church needs is leaders who are becoming increasingly dependent upon the work of the Holy Spirit in their lives and who submit to the headship of Jesus. Nearly every church leader would…